"One God is God of both (as poets feign); Numberless instances might be produced to show with how little scruple the printers, and even the authors of that time, pillaged one another. A song, which is inserted in Lylly's Alexander, and Campaspe, in Blount's republication of his plays, "O for a bowl of fat Canary," is appended to the second edition of Middleton's A Mad World My Masters, as "a catch for the fifth Act sung by Sir Bounteous Progresse to his guests." But I find among Mr. Malone's poetical tracts the most singular instance of plagiarism I recollect to have met with. W. L. (whom these initials point out I know not) published in 1603 two poems, one entitled, Nothing for a New Yeare's Gift; the other, The Effects proceeding from Nothing, He concludes the dedication to his patron, Sir William Hide, in which he speaks very modestly of his sickly spirit and virgin Muse, with these lines: "You lookt for Nothing Nothing I empart He has kept his word: for he has done little more than transcribe a certain number of passages from Sylvester's Du Bartas. I should not perhaps have discovered this, had he not been so unfortunate in his selection, as to take those lines to which Dryden has given an unhappy celebrity: "To glaze the lakes and bridle up the floods, BOSWELL. : : THE PASSIONATE PILGRIM. I. SWEET Cytherea, sitting by a brook, With young Adonis, lovely, fresh and green, Then fell she on her back, fair queen, and toward; II. Scarce had the sun dried up the dewy morn 2, 'TOUCHES SO soft still CONQUER chastity.] Thus, in Cymbeline : " - a touch more rare " Subdues all pangs, all fears." STEEVENS. 2 Scarce had the sun dried up the dewy morn, &c.] Of this Sonnet the following translation was made by the late Mr. Vincent Bourne: Vix matutinum ebiberat de gramine rorem 400 THE PASSIONATE PILGRIM. When Cytherea, all in love forlorn, He spying her, bounc'd in, whereas he stood; III. Fair was the morn, when the fair queen of love, Paler for sorrow than her milk-white dove, Mox puer advenit, posuitque a corpore vestem, Non ipsa, o, inquit, Jupiter! unda fui! MALONE. • Paler for sorrow than her milk-white dove,] The line preceding this is lost. MALONE. 5 - upon a steep-up hill :) It has been suggested to me that this ought to be printed-upon a steep up-hill; but the other regulation is undoubtedly right. So, in a former sonnet: " And having climb'd the steep-up heavenly hill-." MALONE. 6 Deep in the thigh, a spectacle of ruth! IV. Venus with young Adonis sitting by her', • See, in my thigh, quoth she, here was the sore, &c.] Rabelais hath sported with the same thought in a chapter where he relateth the story of the Old Woman and the Lion. La Fontaine also indulgeth himself in Le Diable Papefiguiere, after a manner no whit more chastised: Bref aussi tôt qu'il apperçut l'enorme Solution de continuité, Il demeura si fort épouvanté, Qu'il prit la fuite, et laissa-la Perrette. The varlet Shakspeare, however, on this occasion might have remembered the ancient ballad of the Gelding of the Devil, which beginneth thus: "A merry jest I will you tell," &c. And now I bethink me, somewhat like the same fancy occurreth in the Speculum Majus of Vincentius Bellovacensis, otherwise Vincent de Beauvais. AMNER. 7 FAIR Venus with Adonis sitting by her,] The old copy reads: "Venus with Adonis sitting by her." The defect of the metre shows that a word was omitted at the press. This remark I owe to Dr. Farmer. MALONE. I have given the epithet young as it is found in Fidessa. See the Preliminary Remarks. BOSWELL. * She told the youngling how god Mars did try her,] See Venus and Adonis, ante: " " I have been woo'd, as I entreat thee now, "Even by the stern and direful god of war," &c. - how god Mars did try her." So, Prior: MALONE, "By Mars himself that armour has been try'd." STEEVENS. And as he fell to her, SO FELL SHE to him.] I have given this line from Fidessa; the want of metre shows it to be corrupt as it appears in Jaggard : "And as he fell to her, she fell to him." Even thus, quoth she, the warlike god embrac'd me; V. Crabbed age and youth The emphasis must be laid upon "to him," as the corresponding rhyme is "woo him." BOSWELL. To kiss and clip me till I run away!] The latter part of this poem is thus given in Fidessa: the reader, by comparing them, will judge which was most likely to be the original, and which has suffered most from imperfect memory: "Even thus, quoth she, the wanton god embrac'd me; "To kiss and clip me till I ran away." BOSWELL. • Crabbed age and youth, &c.] This little poem is likewise found in the Garland of Good Will, Part III. Dr. Percy thinks that it was intended for the mouth of Venus, "weighing the comparative merits of youthful Adonis and aged Vulcan." See the Reliques of Ancient Poetry, vol. i. p. 337, 2d edit. This song is alluded to in The Woman's Prize, or the Tamer Tam'd, by Fletcher: " Thou fond man, "Hast thou forgot the ballad, Crabbed age? As we know not that Vulcan was much more aged than his brethren, Mars, Mercury, or Phœbus, and especially as the |